Was Made To Appear Without Any Papers & Is Not Prepared With Case: SC While Imposing 2k Cost On Advocate For Sending Unprepared Junior
The Supreme Court on Thursday slapped Rs 2,000 as costs on an advocate on record for sending an "unprepared" junior to court in his place for seeking adjournment.
As a three-judge bench headed by Chief Justice DY Chandrachud took up the matter which which was listed for hearing, a junior lawyer appeared before it and requested it to defer the matter as the main advocate was not available.
"You can't take us for granted like this. There are infrastructural costs involved in functioning of the court. Start arguing," the bench, also comprising Justice PS Narasimha and Justice Manoj Misra, said.
AOR Ankur Yadav was supposed to appear for the Petitioner did not appear, while his Junior, Advocate Satish Yadav appeared, while, AOR Rachna Gupta appeared for the Respondent along with AOR Shashank Tripathi.
The junior lawyer told the bench he was unaware about the case and had no instructions to argue the matter.
Taking exception, the bench said," We are under instructions to hear the case from the Constitution. Please call the advocate on record. Ask him to appear before us."
Later, the advocate on record appeared through video conferencing and apologised to the apex court. The bench asked him why did he send a junior to the court without any paper and knowledge of the case.
The bench then recorded in its order," A junior was sent unprepared without any papers. When we declined to grant an adjournment, the advocate on record appeared. Matters cannot be conducted in this manner. This is doing disservice both to court and to the junior who is made to appear without any papers. Advocate on Record shall deposit costs of Rs 2,000 to the Supreme Court Bar Association and produce receipt of the same."
Cause Title: Dr. Gopinath Tiwari & Anr. v. The State of Uttar Pradesh & Anr.
Click here to read/download the Order
With PTI Inputs
